S P O I L E R S for RJ novels (and for an early episode of "24"!)
Oss here again, describing some things that interfere with the otherwise perfect pleasure provided by Repairman Jack-brand bath salts.
Set me straight, you Kung Fu fighters!
- Legacies. The totally cool Japanese agent. We're set up to like him and be interested in him for the entire novel. At the end, he's captured, stands alongside Jack, escape the cabin and, er, gets shot and killed. Um. So long, Japanese guy. I would've liked to see him kick some ass and (if it were necessary) meet an end more appropriate to his training and promise.
- Gateways. I'd like to have seen Jack kick more ass than he did. The only Jack-like treat we get is his extortion of info from the Gateways manager, which was fun but not enough for an entire novel.
- Crisscross. Having the head of the Dormentalists be a pedophile (and one who eschews curtains) was too easy a solution. If the leader was not a pedophile, what would Jack have done? I'll tell you: Jack would have had to be Repairman Jack, and figure out some amazing way of dealing with the situation (even if it were just falsely incriminating the leader, to create a way to blackmail him) in a way neither you nor I would have had the wit or the balls to do.
(Also, somewhat relatedly, I've gotten very tired of the whole pedophile card being played so frequently in pop entertainment of the past 15 years or so. There are many examples, but one that happens to come to mind is in "24", when -- in the first episode of the second (?) season, Jack (!) Bauer kills a police informant in order to back into the good graces of a gang in which he used to work undercover. And naturally, the police informant is not just any old bad guy, he's also a (zzzz....) pedophile, I guess to make Jack's summary execution of him more palatable to Mr. and Mrs. Couch Potato watching at home. I realize that easy moral trump card is not why FPW made the Dormentalist a pedophile -- it was to have a quick, easy way for him be blackmailable. What I've described is simply a pet peeve of mine.)
- Crisscross. Jack is able to reprogram an elevator from inside the elevator shaft, so the corridor doors open when the elevator is not there. I feel like I'm pretty willing to suspend disbelief, but... if Jack can do this, is there _anything_ he would not be capable of doing if a given novel's plot demanded it? I fear that we begin to get into Roger Moore-as-James Bond territory here, where he can just pick up an instruction manual for a nuclear bomb, written in Chinese, and figure out how to disarm the nuke in 30 seconds.
Bye for now!
-oss