In the scene introducing Jacob, the man on the beach with Jacob tells Jacob he how much he wants to kill him and tells Jacob, someday I'll find a loophole.
When "Locke" and Ben met Jacob in the base of the ancient 3-toed statue, Jacob looks sadly at "Locke" and the first thing he says to him is "so you found your loophole."
That man on the beach is "Locke."
I bet, as others have said, that the smoke monster has recreated himself in the person of Locke, who is decidedly dead, as are Alix, Ben's daughter, and Christian, Jack's father, who also seem to be beings impersonated by the smoke monster.
I take it that for some as yet unknown reason the man on the beach and Jacob cannot hurt each other. So the man on the beach induced Ben to kill Jacob if, indeed, Jacob is dying. Remember the smoke monster impersonated Alix and made Ben swear to do "Locke's" bidding, no matter what? That's the loophole.
So is the smoke monster the remains of the man on the beach, imprisoned in some way and very very angry? Remember the ash around the old house in the woods? Who was that ash supposedly imprisoning? Not Jacob, as we were lead to believe, but probably the man on the beach.
These are all my own ruminations. I like sticking to my own thoughts and the input of you guys. I don't read about LOST on other sites.
This post was last modified: 05-16-2009, 04:58 PM by Maggers.
Reading is freedom.
The mind soars, no earthly cares,
no limitations.
A Maggers Haiku, 2005
Years ago my mother used to say to me... "In this world, Elwood, you can be oh so smart or oh so pleasant."
Well, for years I was smart.
I recommend pleasant.
You may quote me.
Elwood P. Dowd