Polonius7 Wrote:
I tried reading Jim Butcher's Harry Dresden novels but I hated them. For those who aren't familiar, Harry Dresden is a PI working in Chicago who is secretly a wizard. Except that it's not so secret since he actually puts "Wizard" on his business card and phone book listing! And this despite the fact that there is this "White Council" which is constantly thundering at Harry that he mustn't let the mundane world know that magic is real -- on pain of death, no less.
So here's someone who hangs out a *public* shingle as a wizard but who can't do any *public* magic or he'll be killed. Does that make *any* sense?
And he wonders why no one will hire him as a PI?
You are completely, 100% wrong. There is no rule in the Dresden universe about not letting people know about magic. None. Nope. Zilch. Nada. There are seven, and only seven, Laws of Magic:
1. It's unlawful to kill humans using magic, except in self-defense.
2. It's unlawful to shape shift other beings.
3. It's unlawful to forcibly violate someone's mind.
4. It's unlawful to magically dominate another's mind. (Subtly different from the third law.)
5. Necromancy, the summoning, binding, and exploitation of the unwilling dead, is forbidden.
6. Messing around with the flow of time is prohibited.
7. Wizards are prohibited from researching or interacting with the Outsiders, beings from beyond the boundaries of the known universe.
That's it.
Edit: Re: Murphy: She becomes Harry's close friend eventually, but during the first several books they don't really know or trust each other. She's just a cop who has hired him as a consultant a few times. She went off on him when he deliberately withheld information that may have resulted in someone's murder - hard to see that as over reacting. Their relationship changes over time - it's called "character development."
Your cute little rant was completely unfounded. Don't read them if you don't like them, but don't lie about them to others.