webby Wrote:Maybe I just have a different perspective because I watched the entire Lost series twice in the last six months. I definitely saw a lot more talent than that. From pretty much the entire cast, really, but that's beside the point.
I agree, Webby. When first viewed, I thought Josh Holloway was perhaps, along with Claire, the weakest of the actors. I've since changed my mind after having watched the entire show at least 15 times for Seasons 1-5 and about 5 times for Season 6. Yeah, GEEK, LOSER, LOSTIE! I know, and I'm not ashamed of it.
Holloway has more acting chops than I originally thought. But I don't see him as Jack. Too noticeable on a New York City street. He is someone whom EVERYONE would notice. He's strikingly handsome, a standout in a crowd.
Of course, makeup can work wonders, but I still think he's not right for Jack.