+- RepairmanJack.com Forums (https://repairmanjack.com/forum)
+-- Forum: F. Paul Wilson Related (https://repairmanjack.com/forum/forum-8.html)
+--- Forum: F. Paul Wilson Main Forum (https://repairmanjack.com/forum/forum-3.html)
+--- Thread: By the Sword reviews on Amazon (/thread-3104.html)
Pages:
1
2
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - fpw - 10-21-2008
[SIZE="3"]Not so hot. Shows you can please some of the people some of the time, but...[/SIZE]
http://www.amazon.com/Sword-Repairman-Jack-Novel/dp/0765317079/ref=pd_bbs_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1223985354&sr=1-1
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - cobalt - 10-21-2008
There are those dolts out there that know nothing. Some of them even review books. That doesn't mean we should/would listen to them. We know better.
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - Lysistrata - 10-21-2008
Those who are disappointed seem to wish for a strand of books featuring RJ-against-the-bad-one-of-the-day, with a story ending neatly at the end of each book. Nothing wrong with that, but RJ books are about a saga which started very long ago and which is reaching its climax now, with RJ becoming heavily involved despite his reluctance.
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - LolaRennt - 10-21-2008
Hmm...I can't stand when writers stick to a formula and can't seem to deviate from that formula. It appears that the Amazon reviewers are simple minded folk who love their formulas.
It wouldn't make any kind of sense to continue building towards the climax of the supernatural and continue to have RJ involved in humdrum fixits. Duh...
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - DrFoix - 10-21-2008
I enjoyed By the Sword (how could I not-I'm too deep into the character) but I thought this was a valid criticism.
"the books also had a side story or two wherein Jack turns the tables on ordinary criminals with fiendishly clever ploys. For me that was always the best part of the Repairman Jack novels and the most interesting."
The ordinary criminals and the ordinary world provide the contrast to the Otherness that is needed in the composition.
When I first read a Jack novel I wasn't expecting to be taken around the bend when the normal world met weird-and it was so freakin' cool!
And the Otherness mythology in the right balance is strange and terrifying. Too much and it can become a bit tedious.
That being said, I'm probably hooked for life no matter what. But some of the RJ series have been superior for the above reasons. To me anyway. And no you can't please everyone, so who cares.
Chris
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - Tony H - 10-21-2008
drfoix Wrote:i enjoyed by the sword (how could i not-i'm too deep into the character) but i thought this was a valid criticism.
"the books also had a side story or two wherein jack turns the tables on ordinary criminals with fiendishly clever ploys. For me that was always the best part of the repairman jack novels and the most interesting."
the ordinary criminals and the ordinary world provide the contrast to the otherness that is needed in the composition.
When i first read a jack novel i wasn't expecting to be taken around the bend when the normal world met weird-and it was so freakin' cool!
And the otherness mythology in the right balance is strange and terrifying. Too much and it can become a bit tedious.
That being said, i'm probably hooked for life no matter what. But some of the rj series have been superior for the above reasons. To me anyway. And no you can't please everyone, so who cares.
Chris
holy shit!!!! Fwah is back!!!!
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - DrFoix - 10-21-2008
And this time its personal...
Good '80's movie tagline.
Chris
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - fpw - 10-21-2008
[SIZE="3"]I was a little surprised, is all.
I expected some negativity to Infernal -- it's more character driven and Lovecraftian than the rest of the series -- and got it. Fine.
With By the Sword I was unsure how the Kakureta Kao would be received, was afraid I'd made it too complicated, and that the two climaxes would irritate readers. If I took a beating, I'd understand. But the fan sites gushed over the limited and the trade reviews were almost uniformly enthusiastic, so I scratched my head at the 3 stars. [/SIZE]
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - Legion - 10-21-2008
fpw Wrote:[SIZE="3"]Not so hot. Shows you can please some of the people some of the time, but...[/SIZE]
http://www.amazon.com/Sword-Repairman-Jack-Novel/dp/0765317079/ref=pd_bbs_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1223985354&sr=1-1
Hell, the one guy saying it wouldn't be a good introduction to the series and that it seems to be a lead in to the next novel obviously cant read. If he had bothered to read the introduction he would see that you yourself said exactly that. These last books are becoming part of a thread and are NOT to be read first if you intend to understand the series. They are NOT stand alone books.
They're not exactly of the level of intelligence needed when you review a book.
By the Sword reviews on Amazon - Wapitikev - 10-22-2008
Wapitikev's 1st rule: "There are stupid people everywhere...the trick is to avoid being one of them, as often as possible."
It seems that a majority of the Amazon reviewers are not trying very hard.
I enjoyed By The Sword very much, despite specific objections, previously posted elswhere. Compared to literature by other authors in the horror / mystery / adventure genres, I would still rate By The Sword at 3.5 or 4 stars out of 5.
Keep in mind, as well, that those are reader reviews, not professional or juried reviews, and take them for what they're worth.
-Wapitikev