+- RepairmanJack.com Forums (https://repairmanjack.com/forum)
+-- Forum: F. Paul Wilson Related (https://repairmanjack.com/forum/forum-8.html)
+--- Forum: F. Paul Wilson Main Forum (https://repairmanjack.com/forum/forum-3.html)
+--- Thread: The RJ Books --- Ranked (/thread-3099.html)
The RJ Books --- Ranked - berrymastiff - 10-17-2008
1) Crisscross
2) Conspiracies
3) Harbingers
4) Infernal
5) Legacies
6) Gateways
7) By the Sword
8) The Tomb
9) Bloodlines
10) All the Rage
11) Haunted Air
4,435,279) Hosts
I hated Hosts --- the book didn't seem to match anything relative to the rest of the series -- except for Kate dying. Otherwise it just seemed almost written by some other author. I could barely read it a second time.
From 3-10, most are interchangeable. None is significantly better or worse than each other --all are totally fantastic. 1-2 are probably the best books I ever read. 11 is ok. Not bad but not up to par.
Thats my take anyways....
The RJ Books --- Ranked - Wapitikev - 10-17-2008
berrymastiff Wrote:1) Crisscross
2) Conspiracies
3) Harbingers
4) Infernal
5) Legacies
6) Gateways
7) By the Sword
8) The Tomb
9) Bloodlines
10) All the Rage
11) Haunted Air
4,435,279) Hosts
I hated Hosts --- the book didn't seem to match anything relative to the rest of the series -- except for Kate dying. Otherwise it just seemed almost written by some other author. I could barely read it a second time.
From 3-10, most are interchangeable. None is significantly better or worse than each other --all are totally fantastic. 1-2 are probably the best books I ever read. 11 is ok. Not bad but not up to par.
Thats my take anyways....
Hey, Barry.
Mine:
1) Harbingers
2) Conspiracies
3) Gateways
4) Crisscross
5) The Tomb (Rakoshi)
6) Hosts
7) Bloodlines
8) Legacies
9) Haunted Air
10) All the Rage
11) Infernal
12) [unpublished Jack book]
13) [unpublished Jack book]
14) [unpublished Jack book]
15) By the Sword
What can I say. I love the big R.
Harbingers rocked! Hard!
I rank 2-5 as exemplary...Conspiracies is listed second because it is a masterwork tapestry of crackpots, whacked theories and still ties everything (including the entire Adversary series) firmly together, setting Jack straight down the road to Harbingers.
6-10 are all equally good, which is to say well above the quality of most other horror/suspense/espionage novels.
The subway saviour thread in Hosts is one of the best story lines in any of the books, bar none.
Infernal was an interesting bit of character development but...maybe on a second read I'll have a better opinion of it.
Finally, By The Sword didn't thrill me like the rest did...it seemed to be too much denouement from Bloodlines and didn't have near as many "OH! COOL!" moments for me as Harbingers, Crisscross or others. Far more predictable than the other books. And, I have recently come to want a different ending.
-Wapitikev
The RJ Books --- Ranked - Dave F - 10-17-2008
For ages Haunted Air was my second favorite RJ book (after Legacies)
Now I would say Bloodlines & By the Sword have gone top
I am a massive Glaeken fan so his appearance & the first age revelations have moved these books to the top of my list
The RJ Books --- Ranked - John Is Ghost - 10-17-2008
berrymastiff Wrote:1) Crisscross
2) Conspiracies
3) Harbingers
4) Infernal
5) Legacies
6) Gateways
7) By the Sword
8) The Tomb
9) Bloodlines
10) All the Rage
11) Haunted Air
4,435,279) Hosts
I hated Hosts --- the book didn't seem to match anything relative to the rest of the series -- except for Kate dying. Otherwise it just seemed almost written by some other author. I could barely read it a second time.
From 3-10, most are interchangeable. None is significantly better or worse than each other --all are totally fantastic. 1-2 are probably the best books I ever read. 11 is ok. Not bad but not up to par.
Thats my take anyways....
i loved hosts!!!!:p
The RJ Books --- Ranked - Kenji - 10-18-2008
Now, BY THE SWORD is #1 to me. I can't simply rank all series, but I can say #1. BY THE SWORD is definitely #1.
The RJ Books --- Ranked - WPD - 10-19-2008
1) Rakoshi/The Tomb
2) The Haunted Air
3) By the Sword
4) All The Rage
5) Gateways
6) Legacies
7) Crisscross
8) Hosts
9) Conspiracies
10) Harbingers
11) Bloodlines
12) Infernal
The RJ Books --- Ranked - Libby - 10-19-2008
1. Legacies
2. Crisscross
3. The Haunted Air
4. Gateways
5. Conspiracies
6. Harbingers
7. The Tomb
8. All the Rage
9. Hosts
10. Bloodline
11. Infernal
The RJ Books --- Ranked - Bluesman Mike Lindner - 10-19-2008
berrymastiff Wrote:1) Crisscross
2) Conspiracies
3) Harbingers
4) Infernal
5) Legacies
6) Gateways
7) By the Sword
8) The Tomb
9) Bloodlines
10) All the Rage
11) Haunted Air
4,435,279) Hosts
I hated Hosts --- the book didn't seem to match anything relative to the rest of the series -- except for Kate dying. Otherwise it just seemed almost written by some other author. I could barely read it a second time.
From 3-10, most are interchangeable. None is significantly better or worse than each other --all are totally fantastic. 1-2 are probably the best books I ever read. 11 is ok. Not bad but not up to par.
Thats my take anyways....
I could never rank them. Each has its own character, its own powerful scenes, each giving more insight into the people and the Secret History Paul has created.
But having said that, the ones I've reread the most (in no order) are CRISSCROSS, ALL THE RAGE, LEGACIES, HOSTS, INFERNAL, THE TOMB, BY THE SWORD, HARBINGERS, CONSPIRACIES, THE HAUNTED AIR, GATEWAYS, and BLOODLINES.
The RJ Books --- Ranked - DrFoix - 10-20-2008
The Tomb, Legacies and Conspiracies hooked me with the characters, the story and the great Manhattan backdrop.