Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - Printable Version +- RepairmanJack.com Forums (https://repairmanjack.com/forum) +-- Forum: Other Topics (https://repairmanjack.com/forum/forum-9.html) +--- Forum: Off Topic (https://repairmanjack.com/forum/forum-4.html) +--- Thread: Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? (/thread-3249.html) |
Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - Bluesman Mike Lindner - 01-23-2009 PicardRex Wrote:Thats the interesting thing about Batman, one could argue that each of his major villans is just a facet or twisted reflection of Bruce himself. Well, PicardRex, I guess ruin will have its way with us, in the end. Welcome to the board! You'll find lots of fun, good talk, and a little horseshit too. And I'm "Mike" or "Blues". No big deal either way. Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - PicardRex - 01-23-2009 Thank you for the welcome Mike. Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - Bluesman Mike Lindner - 01-23-2009 PicardRex Wrote:Thank you for the welcome Mike. My pleasure, PicardRex. You'll find coolness here. Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - jacobm - 01-23-2009 however, Cesar Romero wasn't a very good one. My problem with Heath Ledger portaryal is that he never smiled. I always pictured the Joker as: even when things weren't going his way. In the movie i just didn't get that sense that this Joker was having fun, which is what i grew up reading. The anarchy angle was fine, but I felt like he needed to yuk it up more. I guess i felt he was too serious. I'm worried the Riddler will need anti-depressants. Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - colburn0004 - 01-24-2009 jacobm Wrote: however, Cesar Romero wasn't a very good one. I too didn't really like how he didn't smile much but the scene with him and two face in the hospital I think was a key example that showed he was having fun with it. But I also thought the scars were more supposed to be his smile more of a deranged made smile. Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - law dawg - 01-24-2009 Marc Wrote:Had he lived he wouldn't have even been nominated, so no.I think he would have been. Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - law dawg - 01-24-2009 webby Wrote:Heh. I voted yes for similar reasons.Ledger didn't take them to get the Joker out of his head. He was always an insomniac by all reports. Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - njman21 - 02-23-2009 the only reason heath was even nominated in the first place is because he is dead if he wasn't dead there wouldn't even be any consideration for his portrayal of the joker in the dark night. don't get me wrong i like heath's work but there was no fear in me when i watched his performance. he was dull no real question what would happen. he was an ok joker. i think its a disgrace that he won this award, i think robert downey jr. was snubbed big time. Heath was a great guy but like i said he was given this award because the academy felt sorry for his family because he's no longer with us. if he was still hear he wouldn't even be in the conversation for this award. the movie itself wasn't all that great either. you could tell thats why it wasn't up for best motion picture it's no wonder slumdog millionare won. that was entertaining i'm sorry i just found the dark night dull and boring laking realism. how can heath win for best supporting actor if his films not even up for best motion picture it doens't make a bit of sense. the academy really messed up this time. Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - bones weep tedium - 02-23-2009 Whoever designed his make up and whoever wrote his lines deserve a pint and a dirty mag, but even they wouldn't deserve an Oscar. He was the best thing in the film, indoooobitably. But the film was kinda average IMAO. :dontknow: He only got an Oscar coz he died, not because he deserved it. Does Heath Ledger deserve the Oscar? - Bluesman Mike Lindner - 02-23-2009 njman21 Wrote:the only reason heath was even nominated in the first place is because he is dead if he wasn't dead there wouldn't even be any consideration for his portrayal of the joker in the dark night. don't get me wrong i like heath's work but there was no fear in me when i watched his performance. he was dull no real question what would happen. he was an ok joker. i think its a disgrace that he won this award, i think robert downey jr. was snubbed big time. Heath was a great guy but like i said he was given this award because the academy felt sorry for his family because he's no longer with us. if he was still hear he wouldn't even be in the conversation for this award. the movie itself wasn't all that great either. you could tell thats why it wasn't up for best motion picture it's no wonder slumdog millionare won. that was entertaining i'm sorry i just found the dark night dull and boring laking realism. how can heath win for best supporting actor if his films not even up for best motion picture it doens't make a bit of sense. the academy really messed up this time. "Realism", njman? We're talking Batman here! The guy is bugfuck nuts! He needs the Joker as much as the Joker needs him! But I'm forgetting my manners--welcome to the board. Hang around, you'll meet lotsa cool friends. |