+- RepairmanJack.com Forums (https://repairmanjack.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Other Topics (https://repairmanjack.com/forum/forum-9.html)
+--- Forum: Off Topic (https://repairmanjack.com/forum/forum-4.html)
+--- Thread: Dexter (/thread-1921.html)
Dexter - Scott Miller - 08-05-2009
Aprilis Wrote:So if Dexter hadnt [SPOILER][/SPOILER]he wouldnt have been a serial killer?
If he had been younger and not remembered it would that have made a difference?
It seemed like sending a vampire to AA meetings to stop drinking blood ...
No, more along the lines of the way Harry nurtured his affliction. Could he have been talked out of becoming what he is if he had been raised under different circumstances?
Dexter - Auskar - 08-05-2009
I think Dexter would be a serial killer no matter what.
The people at Showtime decided he would be a serial killer, so he is. Don't compare him to the books. Nothing is the same.
Dexter - Scott Miller - 08-05-2009
Auskar Wrote:I think Dexter would be a serial killer no matter what.
The people at Showtime decided he would be a serial killer, so he is. Don't compare him to the books. Nothing is the same.
I agree. I just think that at points in the TV series Dexter has questioned whether or not his upbringing is responsible for his condition. I think everyone has murderous tendencies but most everyone is able to suppress them. In most cases where someone isn't able to, it is due to an event or events that have happened to them, shaped them into a monster. Of course this is not forgivable but it does help to try to prevent creating other monsters, or at least less.
I can't compare them to the books as I haven't read them other than the first.
Dexter - Auskar - 08-05-2009
Scott Miller Wrote:In most cases where someone isn't able to, it is due to an event or events that have happened to them, shaped them into a monster.Regardless of Dexter being found (the way he was) throughout his teenaged life and above, he knew what he would be like - from Harry. Harry reinforced the image Dexter had of himself.
One might wonder, who really had serial killer tendencies in them - if not Harry?
Dexter - Scott Miller - 08-05-2009
Auskar Wrote:Regardless of Dexter being found (the way he was) throughout his teenaged life and above, he knew what he would be like - from Harry. Harry reinforced the image Dexter had of himself.
One might wonder, who really had serial killer tendencies in them - if not Harry?
Exactly. He forged a weapon.
Dexter - Aprilis - 08-06-2009
I think Dexter would have been a serial killer wheather Harry 'forged' him or not.
If he hadnt been caught killing animals as a kid he would have continued on his serial killer path without the code until he was caught.
But what if Harry had taken him to therapy instead of teaching him the code - then would he still have been a serial killer? Can you remove the urge from someone who has it?
Dexter - Wapitikev - 08-06-2009
Aprilis Wrote:I think Dexter would have been a serial killer wheather Harry 'forged' him or not.I think he could have coped with his homicidal tendencies...but having to learn Windows Vista would have put him over the edge eventually, anyway.
If he hadnt been caught killing animals as a kid he would have continued on his serial killer path without the code until he was caught.
But what if Harry had taken him to therapy instead of teaching him the code - then would he still have been a serial killer? Can you remove the urge from someone who has it?
Heh.
-Wapitikev
Dexter - Auskar - 08-06-2009
When does Dexter start again?
Dexter - Scott Miller - 08-06-2009
Aprilis Wrote:I think Dexter would have been a serial killer wheather Harry 'forged' him or not.
If he hadnt been caught killing animals as a kid he would have continued on his serial killer path without the code until he was caught.
I agree that Dexter was pretty far gone and probably going to kill so I'm on Harry's side with what he did.
Aprilis Wrote:But what if Harry had taken him to therapy instead of teaching him the code - then would he still have been a serial killer? Can you remove the urge from someone who has it?
Which I think is the $24 question; nature vs. nurture?
Dexter - Scott Miller - 08-06-2009
Wapitikev Wrote:I think he could have coped with his homicidal tendencies...but having to learn Windows Vista would have put him over the edge eventually, anyway.
Heh.
-Wapitikev
Ha.
Maybe it's because I really don't count on my computer for much more than I'm doing now but Vista seems pretty much the same as XP to me-except that the Hearts game sucks ass with how slow it goes.